Celtic Creamery Surf City Information

Step into Celtic Creamery Surf City and you’re greeted with the warm, inviting aroma of freshly churned ice cream that instantly transports you into a small-town sweet spot where quality and care matter. Nestled on N New River Drive, this charming creamery has quickly become a local favorite, drawing in both residents and visitors with its playful yet sophisticated menu. The selection goes beyond the standard offerings, featuring rich, creamy flavors that range from classic vanilla and chocolate to inventive seasonal options that showcase local ingredients. Each scoop is generous, velvety, and crafted with a clear attention to detail that makes it hard to settle for just one.

The atmosphere here strikes a perfect balance between casual and cozy. Wooden counters, bright displays of the day’s flavors, and friendly staff create an approachable vibe where families, friends, and solo dessert seekers all feel welcome. Service is consistently personable; the team behind the counter seems genuinely excited to guide guests through the menu, offer tastings, and share recommendations. Whether you’re debating between a waffle cone loaded with double scoops or a sundae with homemade toppings, the staff’s enthusiasm enhances the experience, making the indulgence feel even more special.

Beyond the ice cream, Celtic Creamery Surf City keeps its menu flexible enough to satisfy different cravings. From milkshakes that are thick and frosty to indulgent sundaes with creative combinations of sauces and sprinkles, there’s a playful attention to presentation that makes each treat Instagram-worthy without feeling forced. The creamery also has a knack for tying in local flavors and seasonal ingredients, giving a unique Surf City twist that sets it apart from chain ice cream shops. Locals frequently mention the consistency and quality as reasons for repeat visits, and the casual, community-oriented setting makes it a spot where you can linger and enjoy a sweet break from the sun or a day at the beach.

Celtic Creamery Surf City manages to hit that rare sweet spot where menu variety, approachable charm, and attentive service all come together. Every visit feels fresh, whether you’re exploring a new flavor or sticking with a tried-and-true favorite, making it a must-stop destination in Surf City for anyone with a penchant for indulgent, handcrafted ice cream.

What People's Say About Place

I can’t say enough good things about this place. My family and I visited Surf City in September for a short vacation, and we ended up going to Celtic Creamery three days in a row. The ice cream was absolutely delicious, and the customer service was just as impressive. Our orders were taken and prepared quickly every time. Highly recommend stopping by if you’re in the area!

SOOoooo good! By far the best ice cream we've had in the area. Very high quality and amazing flavor! We would go out of our way to come here instead of other shops (had the peanut butter cup, cookie dough, and sea salt/caramel/honey). They make fresh donuts also so we'll have to try that next time!

Best ice cream I've ever had. Even their more simple flavors like "cookie dough" far exceed your average cookie doughs. The ice cream is soft and creamy while packed with loads of cookie dough! I've been here a few times now too... if you're feeling different, try the "under the sea by bee" flavor! It's caramel and honey on a vanilla based ice cream! Yummy

This is a busy shop, but the line moves quickly, and the staff is very on top of things. There is a solid selection of ice cream flavors (we had birthday cake, cookies and cream, and banana toffee), and you can get a milkshake, cone, waffle cone, cup...all of the usual ice cream-y choices, basically. Prices are what you'd expect, and one scoop in a waffle cone was just the right amount for me. Everyone enjoyed their flavor, which is all that you can ask for!

The absolute best ice cream place in the Topsail area by far, and I would vote it best ice cream place in all of North Carolina. The ice cream is amazing, the specialty sundaes and options are utterly brilliant, and the theme is great. They hustle to move the line fast also. This place is an utter gem and worth going out of your way to find.

Some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Kids loved it. Every flavor we had was really good with a special twist.

Best of the best ice cream! My family and friends plan and talk about when we are going to visit the shop before we even arrive in Topsail for vacation. This place is a visit once or twice a day kind of place! Owner is great, staff is very friendly. Shop is very clean and they handle crowds well! Can’t wait until the next visit!

This is a must to get ice cream when you come down to surf city ! We have tried a few different places but the taste is so rich and creamy and smooth . If you have sensory issues with food they allow you to try it before you commit !